49ers-Falcons

49ers Trade
MLB Pakrick Willis 97 OVR 30 6.32 cap hit
HB Kenjon Barner 65 OVR 26 710k cap hit
3rd 2017

Falcons Trade
1st 2016
1st 2017
3rd 2016
MLB Sean Weatherspoon 82 27 1.41 cap hit

Niners agree

I suppose based on the players, picks and the actual owners involved in this deal, I'm okay with it.

Definitely needs a committee vote.

Hmm.. I think Bama is giving up a bit too much in my opinion. According to DL Weatherspoon is 82 overall MLB plus 2 first rounders and a 3rd for Willis and a low rated back. So i'm going to deny this one.

Weatherspoon is an 82 ovr and Barner is 26 y/o

We are talking about arguably the best MLB in the game, so it takes a great offer to acquire a guy like this.

A season or two back I would have said Willis was worth this much.

With the way progression can wreck a player now, age 30 doesn't make me think he's worth all that.

I don't necessarily agree that we should decline a trade because someone COULD regress soon. If he doesn't then I come out of the trade with a bad deal. What about adding a provision that if he regresses past a certain point after this season then I will add the 3rd round pick for 2017?

zoufan wrote:I don't necessarily agree that we should decline a trade because someone COULD regress soon.  If he doesn't then I come out of the trade with a bad deal.  What about adding a provision that if he regresses past a certain point after this season then I will add the 3rd round pick for 2017?

So age shouldn't be taken into account? Ever?

That's not what I'm saying. It's fine I'll add the 3rd in there. No biggie.

I guess i'm alright with the 3rd added in. I approve.

Approved, one more vote needed

approved

Approved